Newsletter

Rodgers & Associates works to help high-net-worth individuals have a more efficient retirement plan, in ways reflected in these newsletters. If you enjoy what you find, please sign up to receive future issues using the form on the right.

Latest Newsletter

When and Why You Should Convert an IRA to a Roth

Posted on

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA) eliminated the ability to use recharacterization to reverse the conversion of a Traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. The process of undoing a Roth conversion was called a “Roth recharacterization.” This rule existed because tax payers often did not know what their total income would be until after the end of the tax year. A recharacterization allowed you to put the money back into an IRA without paying tax or penalty. The Roth conversion was treated as though it never happened. TCJA has eliminated this rule starting in 2018. All conversions are now final when made.

Converting an IRA to a Roth creates a taxable event on any amount of pretax money in the IRA. The tax is paid in the year of conversion, resulting in all the earnings growing tax free from that point on (providing the rules are followed). You wouldn’t be forced to withdraw funds at age 70½ and could subsequently pass the money to your heirs in a more tax-advantageous way. Why do this? Because you don’t have to pay tax on the earnings in your Roth IRA account when you withdraw the money.

Lifting the income limit on conversions opens the door for taxpayers exceeding the income limits for Roth contributions to make them through a two-step process. For 2018, the maximum contributions to a Roth IRA are limited to single taxpayers who make no more than $120,000 in adjusted gross income (AGI), and to couples with a combined AGI of no more than $189,000. Partial contributions can be made for single filers with AGI between $120,000 and $135,000 and for joint filers with AGI between $189,000 and $199,000. Those income limits are indexed for inflation. However, there is no income limit for making non-deductible contributions to a traditional IRA or converting an IRA to a Roth. A taxpayer could make a contribution to an IRA and then convert the entire amount to a Roth IRA.

Should I convert to a Roth IRA?

Now you know the nuts and bolts behind Roth IRA conversions, how do you determine if this strategy is right for you? There’s no easy answer to this question. Ultimately, each person must analyze this option based on his or her individual circumstances.

In general, a conversion may be a good idea if:

  • You don’t plan to touch the money in the Roth for at least the next eight years.
  • You can pay the income taxes due on the conversion without using funds from the traditional IRA when you convert.
  • You expect to be in a higher tax bracket in future years. Paying the taxes now while you’re in a lower income tax bracket could save you income taxes later.
  • You don’t expect to need the Roth IRA assets for income and want to build an estate for your heirs. In this case, the Roth IRA can minimize the overall income tax burden to the family; heirs receive the proceeds free of income taxes, and in the interim, the proceeds can continue growing tax free.
  • You don’t expect to need income from your IRA, and you wish to avoid the annual mandatory distributions required from a traditional IRA when you reach age 70½.
  • You believe current income tax rates are at the lowest level now and Congress will most likely increase tax rates in the years to come.

A conversion is generally a bad idea if:

  • You can’t pay the income taxes due on the conversion without using funds from the traditional IRA. Taking the tax from the conversion assets reduces the amount within the Roth for compounding purposes. An early withdrawal penalty may apply for taking money from a traditional IRA before age 59½.
  • The added income for the year caused by the conversion puts you in a significantly higher tax bracket (to avoid this, you can have your tax adviser calculate the amount of income you can add before moving into the next higher bracket, then only convert the amount that keeps you in your current tax bracket).
  • You expect to be in a lower tax bracket in future years. Paying the taxes later at the lower rate would offset the lack of tax-free growth.
  • You think Congress will adopt a radical change in the tax system whereby income will no longer be taxed. A national sales tax or some form of value added tax has been debated for years. Obviously, it wouldn’t make sense to pay tax on income now if the income tax will be abolished in the future.

Convert to a Roth in Down Markets

The stock market meltdown from 2008 to 2009 caused many investors to lose faith in the financial markets, with good reason: the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 54% from its peak in October 2007 to its low in March 2009. But for long term investors holding stocks and stock funds in their retirement accounts, this was the perfect opportunity for a Roth conversion.

You’ll have to pay taxes on the money you withdraw from your IRA account someday; what better time than when the market is down, and you can pay tax on the discounted value? This strategy calls for some advance tax planning, so you know how much tax you will owe on a conversion. Then, when the stock market goes into one of its sell-off periods, you’ll be able to convert at the lower account value.

The big advantage of this Roth conversion strategy comes when the market recovers, and the account grows back to its original value, since the account growth from the recovery will be all tax-free! (At least it will be, once you hold the funds for five years and have reached age 59 ½).

Fortunately, 54% drops in the stock market like the one from 2008 to 2009 have been rare. However, 10-20% drops are a more common part of the stock market cycle. So, when you hear the newscasters say “correction”, think “conversion,” since that means the stocks in your IRA are at a discount—and you can take advantage of it.

Still unsure about Roth conversions as a tax strategy? Our financial advisers can evaluate whether a Roth conversion is a viable option for you.

Rick’s Tips:

  • Anyone can convert an IRA to a Roth. There are no income limitations.
  • Before you convert an IRA to a Roth, make sure you know how much it will cost in taxes. You should have the money to pay the taxes in an account outside of the Roth.
  • Amateurs fear stock market corrections and try to time the market to avoid them. They usually end up buying high and selling low. Pros know corrections are part of the stock market’s normal trading pattern and use them to take advantage of opportunities.

You’ve worked hard to save for retirement. How can you turn your wealth into an income that’s designed to last your lifetime?

Now that retirement is a reality, or will be soon, you probably have questions. Here on our website, you can find generalized advice, but don’t you deserve advice tailored just to you?

Clint Krushinsky is here to help you get answers. Simply call him at 717-560-3800 or 1-888-876-3437. He’ll answer your questions and help you get to know us. If we are a potential fit for each other, Clint can arrange for up to two hours of initial consultation with no cost or obligation and no sales pitch.

More Newsletters

April 5, 2018 — Is it Time for a Fire Drill? You Need a Strategy for When the Market Declines.
March 22, 2018 — Will Lower Corporate Tax Rates Yield Higher Wages?
March 8, 2018 — Understanding The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017
February 22, 2018 — Are Your Online Habits Putting Your Accounts and Identity at Risk?
February 8, 2018 — Is Bitcoin an Investment or Speculation?
January 25, 2018 — The New Tax Law May Change How You Give to Charity
January 11, 2018 — How are Fee-Only Financial Planners Paid?
January 4, 2018 — Are You Keeping Up with Your Financial Plan’s Maintenance Schedule?
December 14, 2017 — Why Business Owners Should Diversify Their Portfolios
November 30, 2017 — How We Choose Funds for our Clients’ Investment Portfolios
November 9, 2017 — What Might Tax Reform Look Like Under President Trump?
October 26, 2017 — Why You Should Plan for Retirement Without Social Security and Pensions
October 3, 2017 — What You Can do About the Equifax Data Breach
September 28, 2017 — 5 Tips to Control Your Fear in Retirement
September 14, 2017 — Legacy Planning – How to Use Your Money and Wealth to Help Bring Your Family Together
August 31, 2017 — How Would You Define a “Trusted Adviser”?
August 17, 2017 — How Do You Measure a Life Well-Lived – And How Will Your Children?
August 3, 2017 — 7 Steps to Take When You Inherit an IRA
July 20, 2017 — What Does It Mean to Be a “Retirement Specialist”?
June 6, 2017 — The Impact IRS Budget Cuts Has on Your Chances of Being Audited
May 23, 2017 — Is Your Portfolio Positioned for a Rising Interest Rate Environment?
May 15, 2017 — 5 Crucial Ingredients for a Professional Advisory Relationship
May 2, 2017 — How to Deal with the Death of a Spouse From a Financial Perspective
April 14, 2017 — What you should know about ETFs
March 28, 2017 — What to Expect from President Trump’s First 100 Days in Office
March 14, 2017 — 5 Ways to Close the Retirement Gap and Increase Savings
March 3, 2017 — Tips on How to Determine if you should make a Roth Conversion
February 14, 2017 — The Fed and Inflation: What You Need to Know
February 3, 2017 — How Does the GOP Tax Reform Proposal Compare to President Trump’s?
January 19, 2017 — Thoughts on Improving Retirement Readiness
January 4, 2017 — What Impact Will Inflation Have on Your Retirement?
December 8, 2016 — Maximizing the Value of Your Charitable Giving
November 29, 2016 — Don’t Retire Broke!
November 9, 2016 — How to Deal with the Uncertainty Surrounding the 2016 Election
October 20, 2016 — What Impact Will Inflation Have on Your Retirement?
October 5, 2016 — Consider all of your alternatives before starting a foundation
September 12, 2016 — The Presidential Debate on Financial Regulations
August 25, 2016 — How You’re Saving For Retirement Is More Important Than Ever – Here’s Why.
August 11, 2016 — The Risks of Adding Your Child to Your Home’s Deed
July 28, 2016 — Why a Happy, Healthy Retirement Is About More Than Just Money
July 14, 2016 — How Will the New Department of Labor Fiduciary Rule Affect You?
June 30, 2016 — How Will You Find Meaning, Identity, and Purpose in Retirement?
June 16, 2016 — Variable Annuities: How To Evaluate Whether You Should Keep One
June 2, 2016 — How To Avoid Paying Taxes Twice on the Same Income
May 19, 2016 — What Those Extra Letters on Your Medicare Card Mean
May 5, 2016 — Follow the Rules When Rolling Over Your Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plan
April 21, 2016 — 7 Steps To Follow When You Receive a Pension Buyout Offer
April 7, 2016 — How Obama’s Proposed Tax Changes Could Impact Your IRA
March 24, 2016 — How To Fix Social Security: What the 2016 Presidential Candidates Are Proposing
March 10, 2016 — Could You Be Obligated To Pay a Parent’s Nursing Home Bills?
February 25, 2016 — Three Common Pitfalls To Be Aware of When Taking Your RMD
February 11, 2016 — What It Means When Your Account Is “Insured”
January 28, 2016 — 12 Tax Law Changes That Could Affect You for 2015
January 14, 2016 — Qualified Charitable Distributions Now Permanent
December 31, 2015 — New Retirement Report: You Need To Have a Backup Plan
December 17, 2015 — Is a Reverse Mortgage a Good Idea?
December 3, 2015 — New Law Ends Several Popular Social Security Claiming Strategies
November 19, 2015 — Cost of Healthcare for Retirees: Saving Tax Efficiently Can Have a Big Impact
November 5, 2015 — 6 Tax Law Changes Worth Knowing This Year
October 22, 2015 — Why It's a Great Time to Convert Your Traditional IRA
October 8, 2015 — What the 2016 Presidential Candidates are Saying About Taxes
September 24, 2015 — Understanding Volatility Can Make You a Smarter Investor
September 10, 2015 — Maximize Health Savings Account Tax Benefits
August 24, 2015 — Tax Loss Harvesting: Don't Lose Sight of Your Long-Term Strategy
August 13, 2015 — Failure to Take the RMD from Your IRA Can be Costly
July 30, 2015 — Same-Sex Marriage Ruling Simplifies Some Important Tax and Benefits Issues
July 16, 2015 — Non-profit Pledge Obligations: What You Need to Know
July 2, 2015 — Summer: Time for Vacation, Barbecues, and Tax Planning?
June 18, 2015 — Income Tax Traps: Don't Let Them Trip You Up
June 4, 2015 — Newly Passed ABLE Act Allows Tax-exempt Saving for People With Disabilities
May 21, 2015 — How To Avoid Being Double Taxed On Your After-Tax IRA Contributions
May 7, 2015 — Fiduciary vs. Suitability Standard
April 23, 2015 — Estate Planning: What You Should Know About Asset Titling
April 9, 2015 — Balancing Finances Can Make You Feel Happier
March 26, 2015 — Itemizing Deductions Can Make a Big Difference on Your Tax Return
March 12, 2015 — Not All Annuities Are Bad
February 26, 2015 — Will I Run Out of Money in Retirement?
February 12, 2015 — Should You Provide Financial Assistance to Your Adult Children?
January 29, 2015 — Why Even Long-Term Investors Should Hold Quarterly Reviews
January 15, 2015 — Here Are 6 Ways to Make the Shift From Working to Retirement Smoother
December 18, 2014 — How To Legally Transfer After-Tax Money Into a Tax-Free Roth IRA
December 4, 2014 — Changes to Entitlement Programs, the Tax Code, and Retirement Savings Plans: What to Expect in 2015
November 20, 2014 — How the Death of a Spouse Affects Taxes and Retirement Income
November 6, 2014 — Pay Some Tax Now To Avoid Possibly Paying More Later
October 23, 2014 — Don’t Let Procrastination Doom Your Retirement
October 9, 2014 — Don’t Be an Easy Target for Identity Thieves
September 25, 2014 — Reduce Your Death Tax with a Personal Residence Trust
September 11, 2014 — The Surprisingly Simple Key to Successful Wealth Transfers: Good Communication
August 28, 2014 — One Year Before Retirement – Will You Be Ready?
August 14, 2014 — The Tax Advantages of Charitable Remainder Trusts
July 31, 2014 — Employee or Employer: Who Really Wins With Lump-Sum Pension Payouts?
July 17, 2014 — The IRS Has Unprecedented Access to Your Foreign Account Information: Here’s What You Need To Know
July 3, 2014 — Why 70% of Wealth Never Transfers to a Third Generation
June 19, 2014 — Retirement Planning and the Surviving Spouse By Rick Rodgers
June 5, 2014 — Consider Roth IRA’s to Balance Your Retirement Savings Strategy
May 22, 2014 — Maximizing Social Security Benefits
May 8, 2014 — Important New Rules for IRA Rollovers
April 24, 2014 — 8 Investment Decisions That Can Have a Huge Impact on Your Taxes
April 10, 2014 — Could the President’s Budget Proposal Hurt Retirees?
March 27, 2014 — What You Need to Know About the New MyRA
March 13, 2014 — How to Manage Risk in Your Retirement
February 27, 2014 — Why a Fiduciary Relationship May be Critical to Your Financial Well-being
February 13, 2014 — When Should You Take Social Security?
January 30, 2014 — Having a Written Plan Can Increase Your Odds of Retiring
January 22, 2014 — Retirement FAQs – Answers to Your Rollover Questions
January 8, 2014 — What a Year for Stocks
January 1, 2014 — Tips for Reviewing Your Life Insurance Needs
December 25, 2013 — Merry Christmas from Rodgers & Associates!
December 18, 2013 — New Year’s Resolution – Review Your Credit Report
December 11, 2013 — What You Need to Know About RMDs
December 4, 2013 — 5 Steps to a Successful NUA transaction
November 27, 2013 — Thanksgiving Thoughts
November 20, 2013 — After the Great Panic of 2008, What is the State of Retirement in America?
November 13, 2013 — What’s Your Strategy to Defeat Inflation?
November 6, 2013 — Do You Still Need Your Trust?
October 30, 2013 — Is There Good News About Retirement Savings?
October 23, 2013 — More Common Retirement Questions
October 16, 2013 — Spending – The Overlooked Part of the Retirement Equation
October 9, 2013 — Drop Dead Date for Withdrawing Excess Contributions to Your IRA
October 2, 2013 — It’s Time to Start Your Year-End Tax Planning
September 25, 2013 — Three More Questions Retirees Ask
September 18, 2013 — ATRA12 Offers New Opportunities for Roth 401(k) Conversions
September 11, 2013 — New Opportunities with Healthcare Marketplaces
September 4, 2013 — Should Retirees Invest for Yield or Total Return?
August 28, 2013 — Who Insures Your Pension?
August 21, 2013 — Don’t Miss the Qualified IRA Charitable Distribution (QCD) Opportunity to Save on Taxes!
August 14, 2013 — What is Derailing Your Retirement?
August 7, 2013 — A Look at States’ Impact on Your Tax Burden
July 31, 2013 — Managing Student Loan Debt
July 24, 2013 — Common Questions About Social Security
July 17, 2013 — What Happens if You Die Without a Will?
July 10, 2013 — Can You Retire on a Fixed Income Today?
July 3, 2013 — What’s Happening With Tax Reform?
June 26, 2013 — Has Planning for Retirement Ever Been More Difficult?
June 19, 2013 — Are We Ready for a National Sales Tax?
June 12, 2013 — What’s Driving the Stock Market and Can It Continue?
June 5, 2013 — Do Bonds Have a Place in Your Portfolio Even at Today’s Low Interest Rates?
May 29, 2013 — Estate Planning Options for Parents of Minor Children
May 22, 2013 — Emotional Decisions About Money Can Have Unintended Consequences
May 15, 2013 — What Does Your Adviser Bring to the Table?
May 8, 2013 — ESOP’s May Help in Business Owners Succession Planning
May 1, 2013 — Teach Your Children Well – Or They Are Likely to Waste Their Inheritance
April 24, 2013 — Follow the Rules When Rolling Over Your Pension to an IRA
April 17, 2013 — Can You Eliminate Your State’s Estate or Death Tax?
April 10, 2013 — Teaching Your Children and Grandchildren the Basics of Money
April 3, 2013 — What You Need to Know About IRA Withdrawals
March 27, 2013 — Options for Investing Your IRA
March 20, 2013 — Hardship Withdrawals – What are the Real Costs?
March 13, 2013 — 9 Ways to Beat the Medicare Surtax – Part 3
March 6, 2013 — 9 Ways to Beat the Medicare Surtax – Part 2
February 27, 2013 — 9 Ways to Beat the Medicare Surtax – Part 1
February 20, 2013 — Ten Tips for Avoiding Charitable Scams
February 13, 2013 — Five Strategies for High Income Earners to Deal with the New Tax Rules
February 6, 2013 — Finding the Winners and Losers in the New Estate Tax Laws
January 30, 2013 — Social Security Basics
January 25, 2013 — Weathering the Storm Before Disaster Hits
January 23, 2013 — 7 Tips for Shopping for Insurance
January 16, 2013 — Understanding the Impact of Consumer Confidence on the Markets
January 9, 2013 — What the Fiscal Cliff Fix Means to You
January 2, 2013 — Avoiding the Tax Penalty If You Take Early Retirement
December 26, 2012 — The Fiscal Cliff and the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)
December 19, 2012 — Reducing Taxes on an Inherited IRA
December 12, 2012 — Dealing with Capital Gains in Taxable Accounts
December 5, 2012 — Avoiding the Unpleasant Surprise of a Mutual Fund Capital Gain Distribution
November 28, 2012 — Strategies to Manage the Taxation of Social Security
November 21, 2012 — What Investors Considering Dividend Producing Investments Need to Know
November 14, 2012 — Stop Saving for Retirement and Start Planning for Financial Independence!
November 7, 2012 — After the Election – Now What?
October 31, 2012 — Understand and Plan for the New Medicare Tax
October 24, 2012 — Hedge Funds – Are They Right for You?
October 17, 2012 — Are Master Limited Partnerships (MLP’s) the Answer to Low Interest Rates?
October 10, 2012 — Lump Sum or Annuity – What You Need to Know
October 3, 2012 — It’s Time to Review Your Trust!
September 26, 2012 — Preserving Your Income Stream Through Retirement – Part Three
September 19, 2012 — Preserving Your Income Stream Through Retirement – Part Two
September 12, 2012 — Preserving Your Income Stream Through Retirement – Part One
September 5, 2012 — Are Bonds Still a Good Investment if Interest Rates Go Up?
August 29, 2012 — Does Your Retirement Plan Guarantee Higher Taxes in the Future?
August 22, 2012 — Should You Buy Pet Insurance?
August 15, 2012 — Three Key Financial Moves When Alzheimer’s Disease is Suspected
August 8, 2012 — 8 Principles of Preparing For Retirement – Part 3
August 1, 2012 — 8 Principles of Preparing for Retirement – Part 2
July 25, 2012 — 8 Principles of Preparing for Retirement – Part 1
July 18, 2012 — Passing on Your Home as Part of Your Estate Plan
July 11, 2012 — Medicare 101 – The Basics You Need to Know!
June 27, 2012 — What To Do When a Relative Passes Away
June 20, 2012 — Countdown to Retirement – An Important Checklist To See If You Are Ready
June 13, 2012 — Social Security – Part 2: Minimizing Taxes on Social Security Benefits
June 6, 2012 — What You Need to Know Before Taking Social Security Benefits – Part 1
May 30, 2012 — Yes You Can Plan for the Uncertainties of Tax Policy – Here’s How
May 23, 2012 — Tips to Make Sure Your Homeowners Coverage Has Stayed Current
May 16, 2012 — What You Need to Know About Life Annuities
May 9, 2012 — Investor Behavior, Not Market Timing, Matters More in Your Portfolio
May 2, 2012 — Reconsider Tax-Free Municipals in Light of Potential Rising Tax Rates
April 25, 2012 — 6 Reasons to File an Amended Tax Return
April 18, 2012 — Lessons From History – Don’t be Fooled by the Lure of Quick Profits!
April 11, 2012 — Retirement Guidelines for Federal Government Employees
April 4, 2012 — 8 Keys to Help Audit Proof Your Tax Return
March 28, 2012 — Estate Planning Considerations – Spendthrift and IRA Trusts – Part 3 of 3
March 21, 2012 — Estate Planning Considerations – Part 2 of 3
March 14, 2012 — Happy Three Year Anniversary!
March 7, 2012 — Planning on Leaving your Legacy to your Children? Make sure they can handle it first. Part 1 of 3.
February 29, 2012 — 10 Ways You Can Avoid Penalties on Early IRA Withdrawals
February 22, 2012 — The Dangers of Rolling Your Company Stock into an IRA
February 15, 2012 — It Takes Planning to Reduce Your Medicare Premiums
February 8, 2012 — Act Now to Prepare for Upcoming Tax Changes
February 1, 2012 — Planning for Rising Tax Rates Using After-tax Accounts
January 25, 2012 — Older Americans are Putting Off Retirement
January 18, 2012 — The Ins and Outs of Mutual Fund Taxation
January 11, 2012 — What You Need to Know About Annuities
January 4, 2012 — Emergency Fund – What It Is and Why You Need It
December 28, 2011 — Stay in Control of Your Retirement Savings
December 21, 2011 — Do You Hold Title Correctly for Your Real Estate?
December 14, 2011 — Don’t Throw Away Your Legacy!
December 7, 2011 — Thinking of Paying off Your Mortgage Before You Retire?
November 30, 2011 — Act Fast to Avoid a Shrinking Lump Sum Payout
November 23, 2011 — 5 Things You Should Do to Prepare for Retirement
November 9, 2011 — How to Gain Control over the Cost of Your Long-Term Care Insurance
November 2, 2011 — You Might Need to ‘Undo’ Your Roth Conversion – Here’s Why and How
September 16, 2011 — Compare Your Wealth
Lower Your Audit Profile
August 12, 2011 — What Not to Do Right Now
Interest Rates and Stock Prices
Maximizing Executive Compensation
July 20, 2011 — When Is Your Beneficiary Not Your Beneficiary?
Understanding Off-Exchange Private Shares
Tax-Efficient Planning with an Inefficient Tax Code
June 15, 2011 — Planning for Pets
Indexed Annuities – a Free Lunch?
June 2011 Newsletter | Indexed Annuities, Planning for Pets
Annuity Traps (Part 2)
May 20, 2011 — Annuity Traps (Part 1)
Inflation in Retirement
Consolidating Employer Retirement Accounts
April 26, 2011 — How to Protect Your Home While on Vacation
Real Estate in Your Retirement Account
Become a Professional Trader
April 1, 2011 — Home Insurance
IRS on the Prowl
2025 Lititz Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
Phone: 717-560-3800, Toll-Free: 888-876-3437