Rodgers & Associates works to help high-net-worth individuals have a more efficient retirement plan, in ways reflected in these newsletters. If you enjoy what you find, please sign up to receive future issues using the form on the right.

Latest Newsletter: Worried About Running Out of Money in Retirement? What the Numbers Tell Us

Posted on

The yield on 10-year Treasury notes has dropped back below 2% and, at the same time, the S&P 500 Index recorded a 15-year average return of 9% (for the period ending September 30, 2019). Many economists are predicting that we may be facing a time of increasing inflation.

This scenario is leading many baby boomers to wonder how much they will be able to withdraw from their retirement portfolios. Financial planner William Bengen tried to answer this same question 25 years ago. His study1 on returns for stocks and bonds going back to 1926 attempted to determine what rate of withdrawal could be sustained through 30 years of retirement. He published his study in 1994, concluding that a first-year withdrawal of 4% that was adjusted each subsequent year by the rate of inflation was sustainable.

The study became widely known as “The 4% Rule.” Bengen followed up his research by adding additional asset classes and concluded in a later study2 that the actual sustainable-withdrawal rate was 4.5%. Subsequently, professors at Trinity University picked up on the research and examined various combinations of stocks and bonds with different withdrawal rates. Many retirement planners use Trinity Study research3 as the basis of their asset-allocation recommendations. Recently, the Trinity Study was expanded and published in a blog4 using data from 1871 to 2018 and examining periods that spanned as long as 50 years.

The worst-case scenario for a 30-year retirement period would have been the person who retired at the beginning of 1969, since the 1970s began with a devastating bear market that didn’t end until 1982. Starting with a 4.5% distribution in the first year, the retiree’s withdrawals would have reached a peak of 12.5% of principal before the bull market took off in the 1980s. Mr. Bengen concluded: “The damage done in the first 12 years, primarily from high inflation, was irreversible.” Using the 4.5% initial-withdrawal rate, the 1969 to 2000 portfolio was the only one of the 57 periods of 30 years to exhaust itself.

Is this period comparable to the last two decades? A retiree who began his or her withdrawals at the beginning of 2000 faced an equally devastating bear market in the first three years, followed by an unprecedented second bear market in the 2008–2009 financial crisis. However, inflation was relatively tame during those 19 years, so the highest withdrawal rate only reached 5.9%—less than half of the peak for the 1969 retiree5. It would appear that a 2000 retiree still has a good chance of sustaining another 11 years of withdrawals from his or her portfolio.

The challenge for the 2000 retiree was not the beginning years, but what the next 11 years of retirement may bring in terms of inflation and investment results. If stock market returns remain at their current 15-year average of 9% per year6 and inflation also remains in check, the sustainability of the 4.5% withdrawal rate will hold. However, that is a question no one can answer.

We can learn some valuable lessons from the 1969 retiree scenario. Allowing the annual withdrawal rate to reach 12.5% caused too much principal to disappear before the great bull market of the 1980s got underway. Our counsel to retirees is to never let annual withdrawals exceed 6% of their principal. Small reductions in spending can go a long way toward assuring that your principal stays intact for the long run. This concept was studied using a rules-based spending approach published in 20067. The study found that withdrawal rates of 5.2% to 5.6% are sustainable in a portfolio containing 65% equities with 99% confidence—provided rules are implemented to adjust withdrawals when needed. This approach is referred to as a guardrail strategy.

Another approach is to begin with a smaller initial withdrawal. We prefer keeping it to 4% at the beginning of retirement. A smaller initial withdrawal gives you greater flexibility and room for a market decline without the need to reduce spending to stay below the 6% maximum. Dimensional Funds’ research shows that the worst one-year period for a 60% equities/40% bond portfolio was the period from March 2008 to February 2009, which resulted in a loss of 32.8%8. A retiree who began distributions at the beginning of this period would have a distribution rate of 5.9% at the beginning of the second year. No reductions would have been needed.

No one knows what the future holds for the stock market. Many argue that today, the S&P 500 Index is fully valued by historical standards. The earnings on the companies in the S&P 500 have nearly doubled over the past 10 years. The dividend yield for the index is above the yield on the 10-year Treasury9. We may only be halfway through a bull market like we had from 1982 to 1999. However, many investors may still be reluctant to take a big position in equities after the two bear markets they went through in the prior decade.

In summary, the 4% rule appears to be working for now. The key to success in retirement is to remain vigilant of withdrawal rates in down markets and practice more disciplined spending when needed. Put off big expenditures until the money has already been earned during a good market. Stick to your investment strategy and don’t let investment fads lead you astray.

Rick’s Insights:

  • The 4% Rule is based on a study of sustainable withdrawal rates from an investment portfolio first published in 1994.
  • Periods of high inflation appear to be the leading cause of portfolio failure when withdrawals are not adjusted.
  • A guardrail strategy, which adjusts withdrawals when needed, may be able to prevent retirees from running out of money during extreme swings in the market.

1 Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data, Journal of Financial Planning, October 1994
2 Conserving Client Portfolios During Retirement, Part III, Journal of Financial Planning, December 1997
3 Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate that is Sustainable, by Philip L. Cooley, Carl M. Hubbard and Daniel T. Walz/AAII Journal, February 1998)
4 Updated Trinity Study Results for 2019 – More Withdrawal Rates! September 19, 2019. The Poor Swiss.
5 How Much Is Enough? by William Bengen, Financial Advisor Magazine, May 2012
6 S&P 500 index average annual return for 15-year period October 1, 2004 to September 30, 2019.
7 Decision Rules and Maximum Initial Withdrawal Rates, by Jonathan T. Guyton, CFP®, and William J. Klinger. Journal of Financial Planning, March 2006
8 Source: Dimensional Fund Advisors, Matrix Book 2019
9 Source: JP Morgan’s Guide to the Markets, October 31, 2019

You’ve worked hard to save for retirement. How can you turn your wealth into an income that’s designed to last your lifetime?

Now that retirement is a reality, or will be soon, you probably have questions. Here on our website, you can find generalized advice, but don’t you deserve advice tailored just to you?

Clint Krushinsky is here to help you get answers. Simply call him at 717-560-3800 or 1-888-876-3437. He’ll answer your questions and help you get to know us. If we are a potential fit for each other, Clint can arrange for up to two hours of initial consultation with no cost or obligation and no sales pitch.

More Newsletters

November 14, 2019 — What should you do if your employer offers a lump-sum cash payout?
October 31, 2019 — Dos and Don’ts of Retirement Planning
October 17, 2019 — What to do if You Miss a Required Minimum Distribution (RMD): Report on IRS Form 5329
October 3, 2019 — Data Breaches are on the Rise: How to Protect Your Personal Information
September 19, 2019 — 5 Ways to Save for Retirement…before it’s too late
September 5, 2019 — Evaluating Where to Retire: Pennsylvania Vs. Surrounding States
August 22, 2019 — Are Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCD) Permitted from SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA, 401(k) or 403(b) Accounts?
August 8, 2019 — Is Your Vacation Home a Residence or a Rental Property?
July 25, 2019 — The Waiting Game: When is the Best Time to Begin Social Security Benefits?
July 11, 2019 — What is Concierge Medicine?
June 27, 2019 — A Special Purpose Entity Enables Individual Participation in PA’s EITC Program
June 13, 2019 — How Qualified Charitable Distributions Can Impact Your Taxes and Favorite Charities
May 30, 2019 — Tax-Efficient Investing: Why Tax Planning and Investments Should Work Together
May 16, 2019 — RESA & SECURE Act Aim to Help Save for Retirement
May 2, 2019 — What We Can Learn from the Habits of Wealthy People
April 18, 2019 — 2 Ways to Help Children and Grandchildren Financially…Without Spoiling Them
April 4, 2019 — 3 Factors That Affect When to Take Social Security Benefits
March 21, 2019 — Why Optimism Can be Good for Investing
March 7, 2019 — How Do Retirees Get Paid in Retirement?
February 21, 2019 — Don’t Lose Track of Your Previous Employer Retirement Plans
February 7, 2019 — Understanding the 5 Tax Filing Statuses: Which is Best for You?
January 24, 2019 — Are Retirement Funds Exempt from Creditors, Including the IRS?
January 10, 2019 — Are You Taking Advantage of the Opportunities that Come with a Bear Market?
December 27, 2018 — Are You Due to Reevaluate and Switch Your Car Insurance?
December 13, 2018 — What Part Will Social Security Play in Your Retirement?
November 29, 2018 — What You Need to Know About Retirement Contribution Limits
November 15, 2018 — Do Target-Date Funds Hit the Target for Retirement Savers?
November 1, 2018 — A Guide to Required Minimum Distribution Rules for IRAs and Employer Plans
October 18, 2018 — Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans
October 4, 2018 — 5 Keys to Financial Success, Revisited
September 20, 2018 — Advantages of International Investments Against a Weak Dollar
September 6, 2018 — Planning an Overseas Vacation? Do you Have Appropriate Medical Coverage?
August 23, 2018 — 11 Things Everyone Should Know About Social Security Benefits
August 9, 2018 — Thinking of Helping Out Your Adult Child(ren) Financially? You Might Not be Helping.
July 26, 2018 — The DOL’s Fiduciary Rule is Dead. Can the SEC Clear Things Up for the Consumer?
July 12, 2018 — Understanding 403(b) and 457(b) Plans
June 28, 2018 — You Can’t Simply “Will” Your Heirs to Carry on the Family Legacy.
June 14, 2018 — Volatility is Not a Bad Thing. Learn to Embrace It.
May 31, 2018 — Converting an IRA to a Roth IRA? Know the Pro-Rata Rule
May 30, 2018 — 6 Reasons to File an Amended Tax Return
May 29, 2018 — How the Death of a Spouse Affects Taxes and Retirement Income
May 28, 2018 — Non-Profit Pledge Obligations: What You Need to Know
May 21, 2018 — How To Avoid Being Double Taxed On Your After-Tax IRA Contributions
May 17, 2018 — What is the IRS Form 1040-SR?
May 3, 2018 — Under TCJA, can Investment Advisory Fees Still have a Tax Benefit?
April 24, 2018 — Follow the Rules When Rolling Over Your Pension to an IRA
April 19, 2018 — When and Why You Should Convert an IRA to a Roth
April 5, 2018 — Is it Time for a Fire Drill? You Need a Strategy for When the Market Declines.
March 22, 2018 — Will Lower Corporate Tax Rates Yield Higher Wages?
March 15, 2018 — 5 Steps to a Successful NUA transaction
March 8, 2018 — Understanding The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017
February 22, 2018 — Are Your Online Habits Putting Your Accounts and Identity at Risk?
February 8, 2018 — Is Bitcoin an Investment or Speculation?
January 25, 2018 — The New Tax Law May Change How You Give to Charity
January 11, 2018 — How are Fee-Only Financial Planners Paid?
January 4, 2018 — Are You Keeping Up with Your Financial Plan’s Maintenance Schedule?
December 14, 2017 — Why Business Owners Should Diversify Their Portfolios
November 30, 2017 — How We Choose Funds for our Clients’ Investment Portfolios
October 26, 2017 — Why You Should Plan for Retirement Without Social Security and Pensions
September 28, 2017 — 5 Tips to Control Your Fear in Retirement
September 14, 2017 — Legacy Planning – How to Use Your Money and Wealth to Help Bring Your Family Together
August 31, 2017 — How Would You Define a “Trusted Adviser”?
August 17, 2017 — How Do You Measure a Life Well-Lived – And How Will Your Children?
August 3, 2017 — 7 Steps to Take When You Inherit an IRA
July 20, 2017 — What Does It Mean to Be a “Retirement Specialist”?
June 6, 2017 — The Impact IRS Budget Cuts Has on Your Chances of Being Audited
May 15, 2017 — 5 Crucial Ingredients for a Professional Advisory Relationship
May 2, 2017 — How to Deal with the Death of a Spouse From a Financial Perspective
April 14, 2017 — What you should know about ETFs
March 28, 2017 — What to Expect from President Trump’s First 100 Days in Office
March 14, 2017 — 5 Ways to Close the Retirement Gap and Increase Savings
March 3, 2017 — Tips on How to Determine if you should make a Roth Conversion
January 19, 2017 — Thoughts on Improving Retirement Readiness
January 4, 2017 — What Impact Will Inflation Have on Your Retirement?
December 8, 2016 — Maximizing the Value of Your Charitable Giving
November 29, 2016 — Don’t Retire Broke!
November 7, 2016 — What’s Next for the Stock Market Now That the Election is Over?
October 5, 2016 — Consider all of your alternatives before starting a foundation
August 25, 2016 — How You’re Saving For Retirement Is More Important Than Ever – Here’s Why.
August 11, 2016 — The Risks of Adding Your Child to Your Home’s Deed
July 28, 2016 — Why a Happy, Healthy Retirement Is About More Than Just Money
June 30, 2016 — How Will You Find Meaning, Identity, and Purpose in Retirement?
June 16, 2016 — Variable Annuities: How To Evaluate Whether You Should Keep One
June 2, 2016 — How To Avoid Paying Taxes Twice on the Same Income
May 19, 2016 — What Those Extra Letters on Your Medicare Card Mean
May 5, 2016 — Follow the Rules When Rolling Over Your Employer-Sponsored Retirement Plan
April 21, 2016 — 7 Steps To Follow When You Receive a Pension Buyout Offer
April 7, 2016 — How Obama’s Proposed Tax Changes Could Impact Your IRA
March 10, 2016 — Could You Be Obligated To Pay a Parent’s Nursing Home Bills?
February 25, 2016 — Three Common Pitfalls To Be Aware of When Taking Your RMD
February 11, 2016 — What It Means When Your Account Is “Insured”
January 14, 2016 — Qualified Charitable Distributions Now Permanent
December 31, 2015 — New Retirement Report: You Need To Have a Backup Plan
December 17, 2015 — Is a Reverse Mortgage a Good Idea?
December 3, 2015 — New Law Ends Several Popular Social Security Claiming Strategies
November 19, 2015 — Cost of Healthcare for Retirees: Saving Tax Efficiently Can Have a Big Impact
September 24, 2015 — Understanding Volatility Can Make You a Smarter Investor
September 10, 2015 — Maximize Health Savings Account Tax Benefits
August 24, 2015 — Tax Loss Harvesting: Don't Lose Sight of Your Long-Term Strategy
August 13, 2015 — Failure to Take the RMD from Your IRA Can be Costly
June 18, 2015 — Income Tax Traps: Don't Let Them Trip You Up
May 7, 2015 — Fiduciary vs. Suitability Standard
April 23, 2015 — Estate Planning: What You Should Know About Asset Titling
April 9, 2015 — Balancing Finances Can Make You Feel Happier
March 26, 2015 — Itemizing Deductions Can Make a Big Difference on Your Tax Return
March 12, 2015 — Not All Annuities Are Bad
February 26, 2015 — Will I Run Out of Money in Retirement?
February 12, 2015 — Should You Provide Financial Assistance to Your Adult Children?
January 29, 2015 — Why Even Long-Term Investors Should Hold Quarterly Reviews
January 15, 2015 — Here Are 6 Ways to Make the Shift From Working to Retirement Smoother
December 18, 2014 — How To Legally Transfer After-Tax Money Into a Tax-Free Roth IRA
October 23, 2014 — Don’t Let Procrastination Doom Your Retirement
September 25, 2014 — Reduce Your Death Tax with a Personal Residence Trust
September 11, 2014 — The Surprisingly Simple Key to Successful Wealth Transfers: Good Communication
August 28, 2014 — One Year Before Retirement – Will You Be Ready?
August 14, 2014 — The Tax Advantages of Charitable Remainder Trusts
July 31, 2014 — Employee or Employer: Who Really Wins With Lump-Sum Pension Payouts?
July 17, 2014 — The IRS Has Unprecedented Access to Your Foreign Account Information: Here’s What You Need To Know
July 3, 2014 — Why 70% of Wealth Never Transfers to a Third Generation
June 19, 2014 — Retirement Planning and the Surviving Spouse By Rick Rodgers
June 5, 2014 — Consider Roth IRA’s to Balance Your Retirement Savings Strategy
May 22, 2014 — Maximizing Social Security Benefits
May 8, 2014 — Important New Rules for IRA Rollovers
April 24, 2014 — 8 Investment Decisions That Can Have a Huge Impact on Your Taxes
March 13, 2014 — How to Manage Risk in Your Retirement
February 27, 2014 — Why a Fiduciary Relationship May be Critical to Your Financial Well-being
February 13, 2014 — When Should You Take Social Security?
January 30, 2014 — Having a Written Plan Can Increase Your Odds of Retiring
January 22, 2014 — Retirement FAQs – Answers to Your Rollover Questions
January 1, 2014 — Tips for Reviewing Your Life Insurance Needs
December 11, 2013 — What You Need to Know About RMDs
November 13, 2013 — What’s Your Strategy to Defeat Inflation?
November 6, 2013 — Do You Still Need Your Trust?
October 23, 2013 — More Common Retirement Questions
October 16, 2013 — Spending – The Overlooked Part of the Retirement Equation
October 9, 2013 — Drop Dead Date for Withdrawing Excess Contributions to Your IRA
October 2, 2013 — It’s Time to Start Your Year-End Tax Planning
September 25, 2013 — Three More Questions Retirees Ask
September 4, 2013 — Should Retirees Invest for Yield or Total Return?
August 28, 2013 — Who Insures Your Pension?
August 21, 2013 — Don’t Miss the Qualified IRA Charitable Distribution (QCD) Opportunity to Save on Taxes!
July 24, 2013 — Common Questions About Social Security
July 17, 2013 — What Happens if You Die Without a Will?
June 26, 2013 — Has Planning for Retirement Ever Been More Difficult?
June 19, 2013 — Are We Ready for a National Sales Tax?
June 12, 2013 — What’s Driving the Stock Market and Can It Continue?
May 29, 2013 — Estate Planning Options for Parents of Minor Children
May 8, 2013 — ESOP’s May Help in Business Owners Succession Planning
May 1, 2013 — Teach Your Children Well – Or They Are Likely to Waste Their Inheritance
April 17, 2013 — Can You Eliminate Your State’s Estate or Death Tax?
April 10, 2013 — Teaching Your Children and Grandchildren the Basics of Money
April 3, 2013 — What You Need to Know About IRA Withdrawals
March 20, 2013 — Hardship Withdrawals – What are the Real Costs?
March 13, 2013 — 9 Ways to Beat the Medicare Surtax – Part 3
March 6, 2013 — 9 Ways to Beat the Medicare Surtax – Part 2
February 27, 2013 — 9 Ways to Beat the Medicare Surtax – Part 1
February 13, 2013 — Five Strategies for High Income Earners to Deal with the New Tax Rules
January 30, 2013 — Social Security Basics
January 16, 2013 — Understanding the Impact of Consumer Confidence on the Markets
December 26, 2012 — The Fiscal Cliff and the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)
December 19, 2012 — Reducing Taxes on an Inherited IRA
December 12, 2012 — Dealing with Capital Gains in Taxable Accounts
December 5, 2012 — Avoiding the Unpleasant Surprise of a Mutual Fund Capital Gain Distribution
November 28, 2012 — Strategies to Manage the Taxation of Social Security
November 14, 2012 — Stop Saving for Retirement and Start Planning for Financial Independence!
October 31, 2012 — Understand and Plan for the New Medicare Tax
October 10, 2012 — Lump Sum or Annuity – What You Need to Know
October 3, 2012 — It’s Time to Review Your Trust!
September 26, 2012 — Preserving Your Income Stream Through Retirement – Part Three
September 19, 2012 — Preserving Your Income Stream Through Retirement – Part Two
September 12, 2012 — Preserving Your Income Stream Through Retirement – Part One
September 5, 2012 — Are Bonds Still a Good Investment if Interest Rates Go Up?
August 22, 2012 — Should You Buy Pet Insurance?
August 8, 2012 — 8 Principles of Preparing For Retirement – Part 3
August 1, 2012 — 8 Principles of Preparing for Retirement – Part 2
July 25, 2012 — 8 Principles of Preparing for Retirement – Part 1
July 18, 2012 — Passing on Your Home as Part of Your Estate Plan
July 11, 2012 — Medicare 101 – The Basics You Need to Know!
June 27, 2012 — What To Do When a Relative Passes Away
June 20, 2012 — Countdown to Retirement – An Important Checklist To See If You Are Ready
June 13, 2012 — Social Security – Part 2: Minimizing Taxes on Social Security Benefits
June 6, 2012 — What You Need to Know Before Taking Social Security Benefits – Part 1
May 23, 2012 — Tips to Make Sure Your Homeowners Coverage Has Stayed Current
May 9, 2012 — Investor Behavior, Not Market Timing, Matters More in Your Portfolio
April 11, 2012 — Retirement Guidelines for Federal Government Employees
April 4, 2012 — 8 Keys to Help Audit Proof Your Tax Return
March 28, 2012 — Estate Planning Considerations – Spendthrift and IRA Trusts – Part 3 of 3
March 21, 2012 — Estate Planning Considerations – Part 2 of 3
March 7, 2012 — Planning on Leaving your Legacy to your Children? Make sure they can handle it first. Part 1 of 3.
February 29, 2012 — 10 Ways You Can Avoid Penalties on Early IRA Withdrawals
February 22, 2012 — The Dangers of Rolling Your Company Stock into an IRA
February 15, 2012 — It Takes Planning to Reduce Your Medicare Premiums
January 11, 2012 — What You Need to Know About Annuities
December 28, 2011 — Stay in Control of Your Retirement Savings
December 21, 2011 — Do You Hold Title Correctly for Your Real Estate?
December 14, 2011 — Don’t Throw Away Your Legacy!
December 7, 2011 — Thinking of Paying off Your Mortgage Before You Retire?
November 23, 2011 — 5 Things You Should Do to Prepare for Retirement
September 16, 2011 — Compare Your Wealth
Lower Your Audit Profile
August 12, 2011 — What Not to Do Right Now
Maximizing Executive Compensation
July 20, 2011 — When Is Your Beneficiary Not Your Beneficiary?
June 15, 2011 — Planning for Pets
June 2011 Newsletter | Indexed Annuities, Planning for Pets
Annuity Traps (Part 2)
May 20, 2011 — Annuity Traps (Part 1)
Consolidating Employer Retirement Accounts
2025 Lititz Pike, Lancaster, PA 17601
Phone: 717-560-3800, Toll-Free: 888-876-3437